Blue Buffalo vs Pedigree Which One is The Best?

This post may contain affiliate links. If you use these links to buy something we may earn a small commission. Thanks.

Meta Description: Blue Buffalo vs Pedigree, which one should you get? These are two major brands in the pet food industry. Indeed, you can expect the highest quality ingredients. Also, the price you pay will be worth the value you get. Give your furry friends the most delicious food that keeps them healthy!

We all know how complicated it is to find excellent pet food. We want to give our dogs the best food to keep them healthy as pet owners. But the most expensive dog food doesn’t always mean better. Not to forget that when our furry buddy is too picky, they won’t want it anyway. No matter how excellent and pricey the products are, they just don’t care. That’s why it’s crucial to find the perfect dog food that your little buddy actually loves. Now let’s compare two of the most popular dog food brands. Blue Buffalo vs Pedigree, which one is the best? We’ll break down the nutrition facts, ingredients, and all about these products. That way, you’ll know which one to choose.

There’s no doubt that Pedigree and Blue Buffalo are the market leaders when it comes to pet food. These two major brands have been innovating for years. Even when new competitors are appearing, their positions are still irreplaceable. In this comparison, we’ll dig deeper into every little detail. Just because the product is expensive, it doesn’t always translate to taste & quality. Both Blue Buffalo and Pedigree are available all across the states. You can buy them online and offline easily. SO which one is truly the best for your four-legged buddy? Let’s find out!

Blue Buffalo and Pedigree

Blue Buffalo is a well-established pet food manufacturer built in 2003. They promise to consistently produce the best possible pet food with high-quality ingredients. In fact, the healthy ingredient is part of the company’s history. This is the root of why the founders founded Blue Buffalo. While other brands produce healthy pet food just to follow the trend, Blue Buffalo is different. This brand prioritizes real meat as the primary ingredient. Besides the high-quality ingredients, all the products also undergo 6-point quality assurance. They make sure the products meet the high standard of the FDA. Another great thing about Blue Buffalo is the company’s values. This brand is inspired to do better for all pets. They also contribute to philanthropic initiatives to make this world a better place. See how this product compared to other products on Nutrisource vs Blue Buffalo.

Pedigree is one of those pet food brands stuck on your mind. Well, this brand has been on the market for more than 30 years. It makes sense why people always remember Pedigree when choosing pet food for their furry friends. Pedigree is owned by Mars Petcare. However, they launched a different brand name before settling on Pedigree. And since they perfected the formula, Pedigree has been a massive success until this day. Not only can you find the products in the US, but Pedigree’s products can also be found overseas. Some of them are among the best dog foods for sensitive stomach.

The best thing about this brand is its affordability. Pedigree always strives to produce high-quality pet food at the best price. Also, their product selection is massive. You can find products for any stage of life. Also, you have plenty of options for your dog’s particular needs. So between Pedigree and Blue Buffalo, which one is the best? Let’s see the comparison table below to find out which one is better.


Blue Buffalo vs Pedigree Comparison Table

 Blue BuffaloPedigree
Protein sourceBeef, bison, chicken, duck, fish, lamb, pork, rabbit, turkey, venisonChicken, beef, lamb
Carbs sourceBrown rice, barley, oatmeal, peas, potatoesWhole grain corn, whole grain wheat
Vegetables and fruitsTomatoes, blueberries, cranberries, barley grass, turmeric, kelpCarrots
FiberDried chicory rootDried beet pulp, soybean, dried peas
Fatty acidsOmega-3, Omega-6Omega-6
Exclusive ingredientLifeSource Bits
Grain-freeFreedom Grain-Free, Wilderness, Basics Limited Ingredient Diet linesChoice Cuts line
VarietyDry food, wet food, treats. 7 lines with 11 unique formulas available.Dry food, wet food, treats. 8 lines with 3 life stages.
Recall history2007, Melamine 2010, Toxic levels of vitamin D 2015, Salmonella 2015, Presence of Propylene Glycol 2016, Mold 2017, Elevated beef thyroid hormone 2017, Presence of aluminium 2017, Foil Seal Packaging Problem2014, Metal fragments 2014, Presence of foreign material
PriceStarts from around $2.63 per poundStarts from around $0.79 per pound

Which one is better?

Which one to buy? Both are well-established brands in the market. We know it can be hard to compare between these two. Blue Buffalo and Pedigree are head to head regarding ingredient quality. So to find out which one is better for your dog, we need to break down the content. We’ll explain the protein and carbs sources, the special blend, and the product variety further. That way, you’ll better understand the product and can pick wisely.

Protein Source

Protein sits on top of the list because it is the most essential. If you want your four-legged buddy to grow bigger and healthier, pay more attention to the protein source. Make sure to buy a product with a high-quality protein source. Many products offer low-quality protein, which is terrible for your dog’s health.

Which one provides more protein? In this category, Blue Buffalo is the winner. Blue Buffalo offers beef, bison, chicken, duck, fish, lamb, pork, rabbit, turkey, and venison. Pedigree only offers three options: chicken, beef, and lamb. However, more options don’t mean better. It’s just that you have more choices for protein sources. That way, you can check which one your dog prefers more.

Carbs Source

Carbs are also as important as protein as macronutrients. Your dog needs carbs for energy. That way, they can remain active and energetic to spend the day running around. It’s essential to pick the right product with high-quality carbs sources. Which one offers better carbs sources? Blue Buffalo or Pedigree? Blue Buffalo offers brown rice, barley, oatmeal, peas, and potatoes as carbs sources. They’re great because they don’t use artificial fillers. Pedigree also offers high-quality carbs with whole grain corn and whole grain wheat as the carbs sources. But you also need to consider your dog’s particular needs. Not all carbs are created equal. Especially if your dog is gluten-sensitive, you need to give them grain-free formula.

Exclusive Ingredient

What about the exclusive ingredient between Pedigree vs Blue Buffalo? In this category, Blue Buffalo is the clear winner. Why? Well, not many brands offer exclusive ingredients. And Blue Buffalo seems to be one of a few that offers a special blend. The LifeSource Bits is a unique blend that contains extra vitamins and minerals to boost the nutrient content. So not only does your dog get natural nutrients, but they also boost the vitamins and minerals to make the product even more nutritious. That way, you don’t have to buy other supplements. This special blend is more than enough to keep your dog healthy and active. 

Product Variety

The more product variety, the more options you have. Pedigree and Blue Buffalo offer many options that cater to different needs and special diets. What are those? Blue Buffalo offers all categories from dry food, wet food, and treats. This brand currently has 7 lines with 11 unique formulas available. What about Pedigree? This brand also offers dry food, wet food, and treats. The variety includes 8 lines with 3 life stages. So for product variety, these brands are head to head.


Blue Buffalo vs Pedigree, which one offers the most value? When it comes to price, pricier doesn’t always mean better. Many products are more affordable but also better. Blue Buffalo’s product starts from around $2.63 per pound. Pedigree’s product starts from around $0.79 per pound. There’s a significant gap between the two. But these brands actually target different demographics. Blue Buffalo is for those who prefer premium dog food. And Pedigree is for those who want to get the most value for the price they pay.

Recall History

We also need to discuss the recall history of Pedigree vs Blue Buffalo. It’s crucial since we also need to know about the track records of these brands. Blue Buffalo has had plenty of recalls for the past decade. Indeed, it’s not a good sign. In 2007, the products were recalled for melamine contamination. And in 2010, FDA discovered toxic levels of vitamin D. In 2015, there was salmonella contamination and the presence of propylene glycol. FDA also found mold in 2016. Then this brand had other problems in 2017 for the presence of aluminium, elevated beef thyroid hormone and packaging problems. However, Blue Buffalo got much better in the past 5 years. In this category, Pedigree is better since this brand only had 2 recalls in 2014 for metal fragments and the presence of foreign material.

Who’s the winner?

Pedigree Adult Dry Dog Food, Steak & Vegetable

What’s so special about Pedigree Adult Dry Dog Food, Steak & Vegetable? Well, this unique formula is designed to keep your dog strong and healthy all the time. Not many products focus on including vegetables in the ingredient list. But Pedigree made an excellent innovation to infuse more nutrients into pet food. Pedigree Adult Dry Dog Food, Steak & Vegetable consists of steak and vegetables as the main ingredients. Not to forget, they also add Zinc and Omega-6 fatty acids for healthy fur. And the high fiber content helps to improve the digestive system. Blue Buffalo and Pedigree are both excellent. But pick this one if you want to keep your dog’s immune system strong.

Link on Amazon:

Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula

Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula is a healthy choice for a happy and active dog. It’s made of high-quality formula with real meat as the main ingredient. With these natural sources of nutrients, it’ll help your dog grow bigger and stronger. Also, the LifeSource Bits makes this product even more special. This exclusive blend offers more vitamins, minerals and antioxidants. Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula is formulated to boost your dog’s immune system. So Blue Buffalo or Pedigree? Go with this if you care about the micronutrients.

Link on Amazon:


So based on our analysis on Blue Buffalo vs Pedigree, both are great products. These brands are head to head when it comes to the quality of the ingredients. If you don’t worry too much about the price, Blue Buffalo should be your choice. They produce premium pet food with a special blend to boost the nutrients. But if you’re budget-sensitive and want to give your dog high-quality food, you should go with Pedigree.

Scroll to Top