Nutrisource vs Nutro: Which one is the best dog food brand

This post may contain affiliate links. If you use these links to buy something we may earn a small commission. Thanks.

Many owners have experienced a lack of knowledge about caring for their dogs when they first get one. Of course, they love their dogs and want to make them feel at ease, but many of them are unsure how to do so correctly. One of the most important aspects of owning a dog is determining the best food to feed them. Sine many new dog owners are unaware of this, they are unsure what to buy for their dogs’ meals, and many have asked for recommendations on the subject. Nutrisource and Nutro are two of the most well-known but somewhat contentious dog foods. Nutrisource vs Nutro has been a hot topic in the dog lover community for a long time, with owners debating which is the best product between the two.

Some argue that Nutrisource is superior to Nutro, while others disagree. This has caused a lot of confusion, particularly among new owners who are desperate for an answer. Here, we’ll go over both products, including the ingredients, quality, and determining which one is best for your dogs and which to help those who are always hungry!

About Nutrisource and Nutro

Nutrisource Dog Food

Nutrisource is a well-known dog food brand that is grain-free, nutritionally dense, and contains prebiotics and probiotics. They are high in Omega 3 and Omega 6 fatty acids and L-Carnitine, taurine, choline chloride, and DL-Methionine, which are beneficial to heart health. Each Nutrisource kibble is packed with flavors and textures that have been carefully measured and formulated to create a 5-star dog food.

Nutrisource grain is carefully formulated and packed with nutrition from prebiotics and probiotics. Many dog owners debate whether this is a good dog food product. Many have concluded that this product ranks above average. This Nutrisource is also approved by AAFCO as one of the highest quality dog foods available, and they are confident in recommending it to new dog owners.

Nutro Dog Food

Nutro is a well-known and one of the best dry dog food brands that helps your puppy’s nutrition from the time they’re born until they’re one year old. The Nutro contains omega 3 fatty acids like DHA, which aid in the development of these organs. They’re also high in calcium, so they’re a good alternative for giving your dog calcium to keep their teeth and bones healthy.

Nutro offers a wide range of flavourful kibbles made with organic ingredients like chickens and whole grains. Nutro is a popular topic of discussion among dog owners because of the high quality of its ingredients. And it is undoubtedly one of the most recommended dry dog foods for new owners.

Nutrisource vs Nutro comparison table

Nutro and Nutrisource each have their own distinct formula that makes them good dry dog foods. And it’s critical to understand what each product has to offer to get what you want. Compare them in the table below to see if they meet your requirements.

FACTNutrisource Dog FoodNutro Dog Food
Protein sourceChicken, chicken meal, turkey, and lamb meal.
Servers around 32% of protein each meal.
Chicken, chicken meal, and turkey.
Serves around 35% of protein each meal.
Carbs source Brown rice, oatmeal, and barley.
Serves around 12% of carbs each meal.
Brewer rice, whole grain, and brown rice.
Serves around 9% of carbs each meal.
Vegetables and fruits Green beans, pumpkin puree, extracted carrots. Extracted tomato, extracted pumpkin, carrot powder, green pea powder.
Fibber Grains and oatmeal.
Serves around 5% of fibber each meal.
Whole grain and barley.
Serves around 11% of fibber each meal.
Fatty acids Omega 3 Fatty Acids = 0.7%
Omega 6 Fatty Acids = 2.1 Omega 3
Fatty Acids = 0.2%
Omega 6 Fatty Acids = 2%
Exclusive ingredients Beef, beef broth, beef liver, tapioca starch, spinach, pumpkin puree, green beans, carrots, pearled barley. Deboned lamb, lamb meal, chickpeas, dried potatoes, sweet potatoes, lentils, potato starch.
Grain-free Small & Medium Breed Puppy Recipe, Large Breed Puppy Recipe.
Nutro Natural Choice, Nutro Ultra.
Variety Adult Chicken & Rice Recipe, Beef & Rice Recipe.
Adult Lamb & Brown Rice Recipe, Large Breed Adult Chicken & Brown Rice Recipe.
Recall history Start until now = no recalls (FDA, AVMA, and DogFoodAdvisor announced that Nutrisource is a recall-free brand). Start until now – customer complains about dihedra after several uses. 2009 – A production issue that led to some bags of Nutro Ultra containing melted plastic in them.
Price Around $30 – $100 USD Around $10 – $65 USD

Nutrisource vs Nutro: which one is better?

The debate on Nutro vs Nutrisource is still going on. But we will try to give a conclusion through a more in-depth analysis right now. Let’s break down some of the key aspects from the comparison table above to see which one is better.

Protein source

A good protein source can aid in determining whether or not a dog food is high in protein and how each protein source is used. Nutrisource meals typically contain 32 percent protein per serving, whereas Nutro meals contain 35 percent protein.

Carbs source

We can look at the carb source’s digestibility to see which one to choose between Nutrisource and Nutro for carb serving requirements. Nutrisource contains a carb source that is difficult to digest. In contrast, Nutro contains a more digestible variety of carb sources. This can be good and bad. The good thing is, you get the best of many sources from one product. And the bad thing is your dog may be allergic to one of the sources.

Vegetables and fruits

Dogs need various vegetables and fruits in their diet, and we will compare Nutro and Nutrisource to see which has the best vegetable and fruit nutrition. It turns out that in the vegetable and fruit battle between Nutro and Nutrisource, there is no clear winner because they both include roughly the same vegetables and fruits in their meals, such as tomatoes, pumpkins, and carrots. Scroll back up to the comparison table to see each brand’s exact sources of fiber.


Each carb and grain source contain fibers that dogs need in their diets. In terms of fibers, Nutro brings a higher content of fiber, as stated in their nutrition facts and source management. The winner of the Nutrisource and Nutro fiber battle is clearly going towards Nutro for the source picks. However, high fiber content is not recommended for malnourished dogs. Fibrous food makes your dog feel full faster. Malnourished dogs need to absorb as many nutrients as they can before getting full.

Fatty acids

Fatty acids are needed in dogs’ food because they need that omega for their brain system. A good number of fatty acids are clearly dominated by Nutro, bringing omega 3 fatty acids up to 0.2% and omega 6 fatty acids up to 2%. The battle of the fatty acids on Nutrisource vs Nutro is so far dominated by Nutro for most of the varieties they offer.

Exclusive Ingredients

The variety of ingredients is a hot topic in the Nutro vs Nutrisource battle. Each one has different types of extra ingredients. Nutrisource focuses more on beef ingredients, which is a plus for Nutrisource because this type of ingredient usually contains more protein. In contrast, Nutro has lamb proteins, which focus more on the flavor your dogs love.


Not all Nutrisource and Nutro products are grain-free, some of them have inclusive grains, and some are grain-free. It really depends on your dog and requirements when it comes to picking the suitable type. Be sure to know your dog’s needs and read the alerts on grain before using, especially if your dog has a sensitive stomach.


There is no clear winner when it comes to the Nutrisource vs. Nutro variety battle because both companies offer a similar variety at the same price. It’s not like you have to choose one and stick with it; you can try anything and switch to another flavor if your dog favors one.

Recall history

Both Nutrisource and Nutro never had a serious recall. In fact, Nutrisource claims to be a recall-free brand. Meanwhile, Nutro’s product was recalled in 2009 for a production accident where some melted plastics got in their product.


The clear winner between Nutrisource vs Nutro in terms of price is Nutro. The gap between the highest price in Nutro is very high, unlike Nutrisource that is much more expensive for the cheapest product.

Who’s the winner?

Nutro Ultimate & Nutro Choice variants
The battle between Nutro vs Nutrisource is clearly won by Nutro, notably the Nutro Ultimate and Nutro Choice variants, as evidenced by the comparison above. These are the nutrition’s that are used in the competition. It is without a doubt the most recommended dog food for new owners over Nutrisource. It’s guaranteed perfect food for your dog because it’s high in proteins, calcium, carbs, fatty acids, ingredients, and price.

Most Nutrisource variants
Although it didn’t beat Nutro in the comparison today, it’s still one of the best dog foods rich in nutrition and variety. In fact, it’s one of the 10 best dog foods to gain weight and muscle. A plus point for Nutrisource for the array of products is making this product a yummy product for your puppy to consume daily. The price is also very reasonable due to its premium quality. It makes excellent royal food for your dog.


For a long time, the debate on Nutrisource vs Nutro has raged in the dog lover community. Some people believe Nutrisource is better than Nutro, while others don’t. We’ll go over both products here, including their ingredients, quality, and which one is best for your dogs. Each Nutrisource kibble is packed with carefully measured and formulated flavors and textures to create a 5-star dog food. DHA, an omega-3 fatty acid found in Nutro, aids in the development of these organs. Nutro has a variety of tasty kibbles made with organic ingredients like chicken and whole grains. Nutrisource didn’t win the comparison against Nutro, but it’s still one of the best dog foods for nutrition and variety.

Scroll to Top