Fromm VS Taste of The Wild: Which Should You Consider?

This post may contain affiliate links. If you use these links to buy something we may earn a small commission. Thanks.

Your Chihuahua, Beagle, or Bully is an important part of your family, which means his well-being is very crucial. However, there are so many pet food brands, which is why we’ve decided to compare Fromm vs taste of the Wild. Then, at least it may be easier for you to decide which to include in your next list if you usually feed a rotation of different foods.

As with most comparisons, however, the trend is still the same, covered with both inspiring and discouraging stories. But as our team has always done it, we’ll look at the three sides of the companies, including the taste, nutritional value, safety.

Before coming to that, though, let’s have a brief look at both Taste of the Wild and Fromm to see where each comes from.

Fromm vs Taste of the Wild: A Glance on the Fromm and Taste of the Wild Pet Food Company

Chart 1:

Facts  Fromm Family  Taste of the Wild
Founded  1904 2007
Mission Provide high-quality and affordable canine food Produce high-quality, safe, and consistent dog foods
First Ingredient Real Meat Real Meat
Dog Food Brands 7 Types  3 Types
Dry Food Flavors 32 16
Wet Food Flavors YES
34 options
5 at the moment
Dog Treats Yes
[12 different recipes]
Cat food YES YES

Taste of the Wild

Taste of the Wild is one of the most discussed pet food companies due to their top-choice dog food recipes. It’s one of the bestselling brands on the market, thanks to the high-quality diets and friendly budget.

While it’s more like an independent provider, Taste of the Wild is a subsidiary of the Diamond Pet Foods. The firm has been in the market for about 13 years now, whereby it specializes in both canines and feline species.

What’s love, this brand has a taste on the high protein, an aspect they have been able to maintain since the initial debut. All the recipes have the first ingredient is real meat, in which case it comes from various sources, not limited to bison, wild boar, fowl, and fish.

From their webpage, Taste of the Wild claims all their recipes feature only quality ingredients that are “sustainably and humanely raised”. The foods are prepared in five facilities, all located here in the United States. See more about Taste of the wild dog food reviews.

Fromm Family

Although not as famous as the taste of the Wild, Fromm is also a spectacular manufacturer, with over 110 years in the pet care business. The company started as a family business, a feature that they have maintained until today.

Officially known as the Fromm Family, the pet food company provides nutrition for cats and dogs. They prepare their recipes in three different manufacturing plants- two for the dry food and treat, and one for the wet formulas. All the facilities are in the United States too, and since the group owns and manages the operations, they have full control over quality and safety.

Similarly, Fromm dog food includes real meat from sources like Whitefish, venison, pork, rabbit, and pheasant, for protein. The firm is dedicated to serving every pet, which is why their recipes focus on different life stages, breed size, and special needs.

Fromm vs Taste of the Wild: Comparing the various Fromm and Taste of the Wild Dog food Ingredients

Chart 2:

Ingredients Fromm Dog Food Taste of the Wild Dog Food
Carbohydrates Brown Rice, sweet potatoes, Whole Oats, Whole Barley, Potatoes, & Pea Starch Potatoes, Sweet Potatoes, brown rice, sorghum, & millet
Proteins Beef, Poultry, Pork, venison, Rabbit, Fish, Fish Meal, Cheese, Egg product, & peas Venison, Pea, Lamb, Fish, Egg, Bison, wild boar, Buffalo, Beef, Millet, Lentils, Dried Yeast, And Poultry
Fiber Barley, Celery, Peas, Alfalfa, Pumpkin, Lettuce, & Oats Cracked Pearled Barley, Quinoa, Fava Beans, & Guar Gum,
Vitamins Alfalfa, Apples, Blueberries, Chicory Root, watercress, & Essential Vitamins Dried Chicory Root, Garbanzo Beans, Apples, Raspberries, & Essential Supplements
Minerals Carrots, Pinto Beans, Salt, Chickpeas,& Supplements Salt, Tomatoes, Carrots, Chickpeas, & Supplements
Fatty acids Chicken Fat, Fish, Fish Oil, Flaxseed, Olive Oil, & Sunflower Oil Canola Oil, Chia Seeds Chicken Fat, Fish, Fish Oil, Flaxseed, & Sunflower Oil
Antioxidants Blueberries, Cranberries, Apples, Parsley, & Vitamin E Supplement Raspberries, Blueberries, Apples, & Vitamin E Supplement
Flavors Cinnamon, Natural Flavors, Natural Flavor, & Oregano. Natural Flavors & Natural Flavor
Preservatives Mixed Tocopherols & Sorbic acid Mixed Tocopherols

Types of Dog Food Available

Just like you can’t have rice from day one to the last, your dog will certainly need a change in the diet once in a while. Whether it’s weekly or after emptying the previous, diet rotation can help introduce your dog to different flavors and prevent issues like pickiness.

Furthermore, each diet usually contains particular food compounds, thus switching it up will allow your pet to get all the nutrients he needs.

As for our subjects, Fromm Family has a long list of different flavors to choose from than its counterpart. The brand has five different lines of dry kibble that constitute up to 32 unique flavors.

Furthermore, Fromm has up to 34 wet food formulas that you can choose for your pooch with dental issues, or in case you need a topper. And for the training sessions, there’s a dozen selection of crunchy snacks to boost your pet’s morale.

Sadly, Taste of the wild has not yet introduced the snacks/ treats, but they do have various kibble and canned recipes to consider. Moreover, the pet food brand has a few special diets to pick for your growing pups.

Ingredients Use

As we know, different food compounds usually pack different nutritional values. As such, each dog food brand often provides your pet with select nutrients for growth and development.

Surprisingly, neither Fromm nor taste of the Wild wins in this one. The two brands often blend their various recipes using high-quality and wholesome food compounds from the farm and the wild. That’s not all.

The manufacturers use real meat as the first ingredient and source of protein. Some of the meat sources shared by the two brands include venison, lamb, fish, bison, beef, millet, and poultry. Some diets, though, also contain non-meat protein from sources like peas, egg products, and lentils. Thus, supplementing your dog with significant levels of amino that he needs for growth and development.

Another thing, the two brands have grain-free and Grain-inclusive canine recipes. So, you can have an option for your little friend with or without grain intolerance.

Even when the quality of the ingredients is a tie, though, Fromm has been in production a couple of decades longer than the Taste of the Wild. As such, the group is pretty ahead on nutrition research, allowing them to maximize the benefits from special ingredients like watercress, Shrimps, Celery, and Cantaloupe.

Nutritional value

True, a complete and balanced diet is the key to ensuring your pet gets all the essential nutrients he needs for overall growth. This, however, doesn’t apply to the snacks and supplements, but to the actual food that’s the pet’s sole diet.
Even when the food is complete and balanced, though, it still has to pass one of the AAFCO nutrient profiles. In which case every nutrient included has to be at the recommended level.

But different manufacturers usually use different formulation ratios on their dog recipes. So, you’ll need to express the nutrient levels on a dry matter [or moisture-free] basis to that you can get a meaningful comparison.

Here are two examples that show the nutrients levels of a Fromm Beef Recipe and Taste of the Wild Beef Recipe. You can check here how we’ve calculated the dry matter from the listed guaranteed analysis.

Chart 3: Fromm Four-Star Beef Frittata vs Taste of the Wild High Prairie Dry Dog Food

Guaranteed Analysis Guaranteed Analysis  Dry Matter Basis  Dry Matter Basis
Fromm Family  Taste of Wild  Fromm Family Taste of Wild
Crude Protein  30.0% Min. 32.0% Min.  33.33% 35.56%
Crude fat 18.0% Min. 18.0% Min. 20.00% 20.00%
Crude Fiber  6.5% Max. 4.0% Max.  7.22% 4.44%
Moisture 10.0% Max 10.0% Max. 0% 0%

Chart 4: Fromm Pate Beef & Sweet Potato vs Taste of the Wild High Prairie Beef Wet Dog Food

Guaranteed Guaranteed Dry Matter Basis Dry Matter Basis
Fromm Taste Of the Wild Fromm Taste of the wild
Crude Protein  9.0% Min.  8.0% Min. 40.91% 44.44%
Crude fat 4% Min. 3.5% Min. 18.18%  19.44%
Crude Fiber 1.5% Max. 1.0% Max. 6.82% 5.56%
Moisture 78% Max 82.0% Max. 0% 0%

From the chart, you can see Taste of the Wild is the winner on the Protein ratio, just like in our previous Taste of The Wild vs Blue Buffalo Comparison. Hence, a better option if your pet needs to add some weight or muscles.

Product Safety

After the taste and nutritional value, safety is the other thing to consider from the pet food. You certainly want to provide your dog with the healthiest meal as possible, with no likelihood of complications.

Anyways, Fromm and Taste of the Wild have been able to maintain their intent on high-quality and the wellbeing of the pets. They both have had only one safety recall, whereby three canned Fromm recipes were noted to contain elevated levels of Vitamin D. Then, Taste of the Wild had to recall a batch of dry food varieties due to potential

Salmonella contamination in their South Carolina facility.
In each case, the firms were able to act on time and made necessary changes to ensure high production efficiency without a recurrence.

Sadly, though, Taste of the Wild has a pending lawsuit that involves claims that select nutritions have heavy metal and pesticide contamination. Although it has been two years now, the FDA investigation has not yet concluded on the issue. Thus, it’s not even certain if these diets are the cause of the said issues.


Taste of the Wild no doubt is the clear winner on the price-point. The brand packs their dog food selections in pounds, in which case the kibble is currently available at an average range of $1.70-$2.80 per pound weight.
On the other hand, the Fromm Family has their bags on average $2.34-$3.52 per pound weight. The price, though, goes on dropping as the weight goes up. So, you may find a 26-pound bag relatively cheaper than the 5-pound bag.

The 4 Best Fromm And The Taste Of The Wild Dog Foods

Taste of the Wild Wetlands Roasted Fowl Dog Kibble

Check Latest Price on Amazon

With high and high-quality protein content, this diet can be a great option for your underweight dog. It can also help enhance muscle development if your pet is exercising well and enough.

The dog food has a farm-raised duck and duck meal as first and second ingredients respectively. Its fourth is sweet potatoes, which work in hand with potatoes starch to boost your pet’s energy tanks for his active lifestyle. No wheat, corn, or any other grains are in the mix, which means it will have no effect on your pet with grains’ sensitivity.

In addition to that, each kibble packs spectacular dietary fiber and Proprietary Probiotics to support Gut health. The meal also contains excellent Omega-3 and -6 fatty acids content to help improve the exterior beauty of your dog.

Key Benefits:

  • It’s a great choice to build weight and lean muscles
  • Has hardworking natural antioxidants
  • Uses natural flavors and preservatives
  • Can help improve digestive health
  • Prepared in the USA
  • Easy to digest
  • It’s budget-friendly.

Taste of the Wild High Prairie Roasted Bison Dry Dog Food

Check Latest Price on Amazon

This diet is the Flagship of the pet food maker. It’s one of the top recipes in the market and a favorite of many dog owners due to its high protein content. Real Buffalo is the first ingredient and primary source of protein.

To meet the intended protein quantity though, the dog food also contains lamb meal, peas, egg product, and roasted bison & Bison.

Thanks to the exemption of grains, this diet can do very well for your pouch with grain intolerance. It relies on sweet potatoes and potatoes, in which case your pet benefits from carbs and rich dietary fiber.

Speaking of fiber, this diet does contain exclusive Probiotics to help support the health and performance of the GI tract. It also has superior antioxidant properties from blueberries, raspberries, and Vitamin E supplements. Thus, giving your dog a better chance to fight the free radicals and disease-causing bacteria in the body.

Key Benefits:

  • It’s well-balanced and nutritious
  • Has high protein for lean and strong muscles
  • Packs natural fatty acids to boost skin and coat health
  • Contains no grain or artificial additives
  • Made in the USA
  • Can help normalize bowel movement
  • It’s highly palatable and easy to digest

Fromm Four-Star Beef Frittata Veg Dry Dog Kibble

Check Latest Price on Amazon

Similarly, this dog food comprises a high protein formulation, with real beef as the main source and first ingredient on the list. It also has Lentils and peas, both of which have protein, as well as fiber benefits.

The dog food is grain-free but still has heavy carbs from natural tubers, including sweet potatoes and potatoes. It also has flaxseed and salmon oil to provide the essential fatty acids, plus exclusive probiotics to replenish the gut flora.

More to love, the kibbles pack superior antioxidant properties from multiple sources like Apples, blueberries, and cranberries. Thus, boosting your dog’s defensive wall against diseases.

Key Benefits:

  • It has no grains to cause food-related allergies
  • Excellent for lean muscle development
  • Can help improve gut functions and reduce stool odor
  • Great to support healthy bones and joints
  • Has Taurine to support normal heart and kidney function
  • It uses natural flavors and preservatives.

Fromm Four-Star Game Bird Dry Dog Food

Check Latest Price on Amazon

Last but not least, is yet another premium recipe that you can consider for your dog with problems digesting grains. It has high-quality protein, most of which from farm-raised birds such as turkey, goose, chicken, duck, and quail.

The dog food features potatoes and sweet potatoes to provide the carbs for energy. Then, there is salmon oil and flaxseed to balance the fatty acid levels while still nourishing the skin and coat.

Like the rest, this diet has a blend of various vitamins and mineral supplements to enhance the metabolism of other nutrients and boost immune system health. It also does pack cranberries, blueberries, and apples, which we know are the kings of the antioxidants.


  • It consists of a complete, balanced diet
  • Rich in protein and carbs to support active dogs
  • Has high-quality fiber to improve bowel movement
  • Includes exclusive probiotics to recharge gut flora
  • Contains cheese to increase palatability
  • It’s easy to ingest and digest.

Fromm vs Taste of the Wild: Which should you Consider?

Without being biased in any way, both Taste of the Wild and Fromm are great pet food brands to consider. They all have shown the dedication to provide your dog with only the best, an aspect we can retrace to the high-quality ingredients and minimal safety issues.

Just like other companies, however, Fromm and taste of the Wild differ in the production process. Each has unique characteristics that consist of both strengths and weaknesses.

For instance, Fromm has a wider variety of flavors and ingredients to choose from. The firm has been long in the industry, in which case they have broadened their craftsmanship and research field.

Meanwhile, Taste of the wild is still growing but their protein levels are usually higher than most. Furthermore, the brand is more affordable than its counterpart. Hence, a cost-effective option in case you have a tight budget at hand.

Similar Article: Taste of the wild vs Merrick

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top